Prospective clients face a complex and high-stakes decision when selecting a financial advisory firm. They're not only seeking credentials to trust, but also an individual they can genuinely trust to solve their specific financial challenges. However, the landscape of financial advice can be dense, and these decisions are high-stakes for prospects – a traditional advisor/client relationship involves nearly all of their life savings and can span years. For the prospect, this poses the challenge of how to determine who to trust, given their lack of understanding of the broader landscape of financial advice. For advisory firms, this poses a challenge of how to stand out to the (right) prospects and communicate their value effectively.
In this article, Sydney Squires, Senior Financial Planning Nerd, discusses how financial advisors can mold their existing marketing and value propositions to fit a prospect's emotional and practical decision-making process. Most decision-making processes are two-part: first, the divergent phase (gathering a wide array of qualified options), then the convergent phase (of narrowing down the list). This process often cycles multiple times as prospects refine their understanding of what they need and who can best provide it.
For prospects, the initial divergent phase involves looking for indicators of general trustworthiness and expertise. This typically includes checking an advisor's professional designations or seeking peer validation of the firm, such as asking for referrals or looking for online reviews. Referrals remain the most influential factor in how prospects find advisors… yet Wealthtender's research shows that 96% of prospects will conduct further online research before reaching out, typically visiting the advisor's website and evaluating credentials, pricing transparency, and communication style.
This highlights the importance of 'supporting tactics' such as SEO, social media, and newsletters – tactics that help reinforce the positive perception initiated by referrals. Even strong referrals can falter if a firm's website is outdated, difficult to navigate, or overly generic. Design, clarity, and messaging matter; poorly executed online experiences can erode trust, while effective ones help convert curiosity into inquiry. The challenge for advisors is to strike a balance between providing general signals of trust and competence to ensure visibility… while also providing specific evidence and information to withstand the convergent phases.
In the end, prospective clients are looking for two things: someone they can trust and someone who can solve their problem. And prospects generally look for that information in multiple steps. Financial advisors who recognize the nuances of the prospect decision-making process – and who intentionally align their marketing, online presence, and messaging to meet those needs – are better positioned to attract and convert right-fit clients. By layering in both general trust signals and information about the specific value they provide, advisors can effectively differentiate themselves in a crowded, often confusing marketplace, creating clarity and confidence for the people they are best suited to serve!

