Managing risks in the face of uncertainty has long been a staple of financial planning. From helping clients evaluate the risk/return potential of various investment opportunities, to recommending insurance coverage against the risks too big to handle, to making decisions about how much to spend today versus saving for the (uncertain) future, the whole framework of the financial planning process is a means to evaluate the trade-offs. Yet with the recent rise of AI, the uncertainty seems to have reached whole new proportions – where the trade-off isn't just the potential for significant growth or a market pullback, but according to some the potential for a post-scarcity utopia, or an artificial-general-intelligence destruction of humanity. Which raises the practical but remarkably difficult question: how should we counsel clients through such potential extreme outcomes?
In this guest post, Zach Bennedsen, CFP, a Product Manager for Advisor360°, explores how advisors can think through the incredible breadth of upside and downside scenarios for AI, and the ways to have practical conversations with clients about how they can plan for and within an era of such uncertainty.
The starting point is simply to recognize how diverse the views are about AI. Proponents of the technology sometimes forget the fact that 75% of Americans are concerned that AI will reduce the number of available jobs (with the risk of wage depression or outright mass unemployment). While those who are bearish on potential AI outcomes forget that prior transformative technologies ultimately created far more jobs than they eliminated (with 60 percent of jobs in the U.S. representing types of work that didn't even exist before 1940!).
For many advisors, the first stage of advice will still be the client's portfolio itself. For clients who want exposure to the opportunities of AI, it's important to recognize that a broad-based diversified portfolio already actually has substantial AI exposure (as the AI-heavy Mag7 stocks already comprise 33% of the S&P 500 as of September 2026!). And that, at least until there are more IPOs, many of the leading AI businesses remain privately held and simply aren't investable. On the other hand, for clients who are fearful of or want to avoid AI, the broad exposure in market indices that supports AI enthusiasts makes it difficult for pessimists to avoid. Still, some paths are available, from leveraging direct indexing or new ETFs specifically built for non-AI exposure… or even donating AI-driven gains into non-AI charitable support.
For clients still in their working years, though, arguably the bigger impact is not the risk of AI impacting their financial portfolio, but their human capital in the form of their job and future earnings potential. Which may mean actively discussing larger – potentially much larger – emergency savings to help navigate a career or industry change should it become necessary. Though for some who expect AI to augment more than automate, the greatest career opportunity for many clients may simply be to continue delving deeper to become an expert in their current field, and leverage AI to accelerate their career further.
Still, with such extreme utopia-or-extinction level forecasts, some clients may simply be paralyzed by the sheer level of uncertainty. For which at least one approach is to not make predictions of how it will turn out, but at least take actions to try to protect against whichever scenarios will produce the most regret. For instance, the client who doesn't want to bother saving anymore – in the expectation that AI will soon automate away most work and make money meaningless – might reflect that if AI really does make money meaningless they will still have many years of happiness anyway, but if they're wrong they may severely regret not having continued to save.
Ultimately, though, the key point is that supporting clients through conversations about uncertainty is not new; what's changed, perhaps, is that at least the current forecasts about the potential of AI have amplified the potential outcomes (to the upside, and the downside). Still, though, that doesn't change the value of having financial planning conversations, planning through What-If Scenarios, and engaging in principles of building reserves and diversification… in fact, it arguably just makes financial planning more valuable than ever!
![]() |
And if you want to go deeper on this topic, hear directly from the author on the Financial Advisor Technician podcast. |






