Executive Summary
Welcome everyone! Welcome to the 516th episode of the Financial Advisor Success Podcast!
My guest on today's podcast is Rubin Miller. Rubin is the founder of Peltoma Capital, an RIA based in Austin, Texas, that oversees $235 million in assets under management for 80 client households.
What's unique about Rubin, though, is how he uses a combination of synchronous and asynchronous communication throughout the year to efficiently deliver portfolio and planning reviews to his busy clientele, allowing his firm to add $200 million in AUM and 70 clients in just the past three years.
In this episode, we talk in-depth about how Rubin meets with clients for an annual meeting at the start of the year but then conducts a mid-year planning and portfolio update asynchronously using screen recording tool Loom, how Rubin has found that this cadence works well both for his clients (many of whom are busy professionals who might prefer to meet asynchronously) and for his firm (which can provide personalized portfolio and planning updates to clients without having to arrange a separate meeting, and how Rubin has recognized the importance of each team member sticking to key due dates for their contribution to ensure that asynchronous products are produced in a timely manner (given that there is no set deadline as there is for a formal meeting).
We also talk about how Rubin has seen significant growth in his firm in part from his blog, which not only lets him give readers a sense of his investment philosophy but also has attracted attention from journalists who have amplified his message (leading to prospect inquiries and new clients), how Rubin managed his rapid growth by making a key early hire of an experienced professional (offering incentive compensation and the opportunity to purchase equity given that he wasn’t able to offer an elevated base salary at the time), and how Rubin was willing to make decisions over time that might not have been optimal for his current-year income but allowed for greater firm growth and long-term profitability.
And be certain to listen to the end, where Rubin shares how he developed his fee model, which includes a flat fee plus an AUM charge for assets above $1 million, how Rubin has found success creating deep relationships with key centers of influence who have referred clients to his firm, and how Rubin has ultimately found success in creating breathing room for both him and for his clients, allowing them to balance both personal and professional responsibilities.
So, whether you’re interested in learning about creating an efficient system for communicating market updates to clients, the tradeoffs involved in bringing a partner in to a firm early on, or how amplifying your own voice can help attract good-fit clients, then we hope you enjoy this episode of the Financial Advisor Success podcast, with Rubin Miller.
Podcast Player:
Resources Featured In This Episode:
- Rubin Miller: LinkedIn
- Peltoma Capital
- Fortunes & Frictions
- Loom
- 2026 Market Forecast
- Dan Solin
Full Transcript:
Michael: Welcome, Rubin Miller, to the "Financial Advisor Success" podcast.
Rubin: Thanks so much for having me.
Michael: I'm really excited that you're joining us today and to get to talk about what it takes to have good investment conversations with clients. The industry trends are very, very clear. More and more of us are focusing on financial planning and offering broader wealth management services. But even our own Kitces research shows very clearly, 90%-plus of us are still operating primarily or exclusively on an assets under management model, which means there are portfolio assets. We do have to be good stewards of the investment dollars, and we do have to communicate effectively about what's going on with the portfolio. That doesn't go away as we get more planning-centric for most of us.
And it's hard. It's always been hard. It continues to be hard because clients are humans, and humans do human things that are not always rational about market volatility or "reasonable expectations," I put in air quotes, of what portfolios realistically can generate year after year. And, Rubin, I know you have spent a unique amount of time and effort and thoughtfulness trying to figure out how do you hone these investment conversations with clients. So I'm excited just to talk today about what you've learned, what you do, what the process is about, how you are engaging with clients and trying to get them to appropriate expectations about markets and their portfolios.
Rubin: Yeah.
What Peltoma Looks Like Today [04:17]
Michael: So, to kick us off, tell us a bit about the advisory firm itself and the team, just so we understand the context of the business as a whole.
Rubin: Yeah, sure. Peltoma opened for business April 1st of 2023. So almost three and a half years ago. I started it kind of on my own. And quickly, as I saw...not that it was working really well or anything as far as assets or revenue, but as far as growth goes, it seemed like I had something that was going to work and some serendipitous timing. I spent a large part of my career before I became an advisor at Dimensional, which I'm sure we'll talk about in a bit. But a colleague of mine from Dimensional had left to travel the world with her husband, Rachael Levine. And she was a good friend of mine from Dimensional. We'd worked together quite a bit, and she had just kind of come back to Austin, where we both live most of the year now. And she had basically reached out and said, "Do you want to grab coffee?" And I said, "Hey, this thing is..."
It's kind of funny. I started, maybe we were at $20 million, and now I'm at $32 million. I think, when she joined, we were at $38 million. But I had seen that, "I think this is going to work. And is there any way I could get someone of her talent and caliber?" She was a very highly regarded kind of senior person at Dimensional who had just had this life dream of traveling the world with her husband. So she was out of a job. She certainly could have gone back to Dimensional or any fund company she wanted, just a highly, highly impressive financial professional. And I said, "I think this growth trajectory, if I can keep it up, we could maybe figure it out." I always approach business sort of like, before you invest too much time or energy, you want to make sure you're in the ballpark together.
So I told her what I thought I could probably accomplish as far as compensation. And certainly, she was going to want equity. And I knew that, and she's worth it. And so we had our first conversation that summer of 2023, and then we were able to get it across the finish line. She started basically about six months after I launched the firm. So Rachael and I are business partners, and we have been since, I think, October of 2023.
And then, in the beginning of 2025, we hired Emily Moran. And Emily is an associate advisor with us. And she also had worked at Dimensional. She worked on the practice management team. Actually, your world. And she had kind of left somewhat recently and was looking for a remote job, like we offered. And so she joined. And then we have our fourth team member joining the firm, actually, in a couple of weeks here. And she's not going to be an advisor. She's going to join as our sort of first operations hire.
Michael: Okay. And I was going to ask in that context. So, what does Rachael do? Is she also in an advisory role, or is she driving the operational side of the business? Where does she sit?
Rubin: Rachael can do anything. That's our problem, is that Rachael only has 24 hours in the day. So where it started is we both did everything. We were both advisors. We both are investment professionals, probably above the average advisor, given our background of, I think, a combined 20 years at Dimensional and talking about the way the investment solutions work and designing portfolios. And then there's obviously someone who's got to run the firm. And we launched with the XYPN kind of association. So they helped us launch. But still, you need help on the operations and marketing, whatever. So Rachael really is fantastic at all that.
Then, I would say, she's much more gravitated to the planning work than I am. I really love the investment conversations, and I love growing the firm. And many of our clients are close friends of mine. And so I also love the service because many of these people I've been friends with, some of them my whole life. So Rachael gravitated towards the planning. She went and passed the CFP rather quickly. And she has basically taken that part over. I'd say in the last year, we moved away from kind of both doing everything to sort of Rachael handling a lot of the planning, alongside Emily, who also has her CFP. And then I sort of do some of the running of the firm, a meaningful amount of the operations and logistics behind that. And then I handle most of the investment conversations, although Rachael is easily capable of doing that part as well.
Michael: Okay. And so, what does the firm look like at this point in terms of assets, clients, revenue?
Rubin: Yeah. We manage $235 million. Usually, because we've been hiring, I think a lot about forward revenue. So that's how I usually measure it. So if we pause today and we didn't grow at all, we would bill about $1.4 million for the next year.
Michael: Okay. Okay. So that's run rate revenue. And how many clients is it?
Rubin: It's 80 families.
Michael: Okay. So you've got a very focused clientele there, just $10,000-plus revenue per client that you're digging in with.
Rubin: Yep. We have a rather unique shape of clients. We are sort of positioning publicly as we like to work with high-performing professionals, time-impoverished, busy young families. Our average client age is 39. So that doesn't really translate to that sort of average assets of almost 3 million, I guess it is. And so where that actually comes from is it's a little bit barbelled. We have a subset of probably 10 to 15 clients who have $6 million, $7 million-plus with us. They tend to be on the older side. And then we have a lot of these younger high-performing professionals who are late 20s, 30s, 40s, and they might have 700 grand to 1.5 million with us or something like that.
We really love those clients. Obviously, from a business perspective, that's an incredible foundation to build a firm off of as far as the great wealth transfer and all these things. So I would expect that to be a great foundation for us to look back ten years from now and say, "Gosh, that was a great investment to focus on those people." But some of our numbers do skew upward to these other great clients we have today who just have higher assets and might be a little bit older than our average client.
Michael: And I'm presuming as well then a lot of the younger clients, that is the higher income, heavy saver type folks as well. So you get a lot of people adding tens of thousands or more into accounts as they proactively save, which helps lift investment growth.
Rubin: I wish they saved more. I wish they didn't all live in California and New York and didn't have the tax burden and saved more. Yeah, that is it. I also think those naturally become a great candidate to outsource some of your financial life when you're just saying, "Gosh, what I would do to spend a couple more nights with my kids every week and not be stressed by money," or whatever it might be. So that's definitely true. We definitely love, we call it, kind of designing the flywheel. So back into the accounts we can max out every year, what we think will be left over, and sort of try to engineer that as best we can to make as few human decisions as possible on that journey.
But yeah, I'd say that that's kind of the target that we love working with people that are kind of open to some objective help from us and then also willing to engineer it so we don't really have to veer off course because of various opinions or thoughts they might have. That's probably a little bit of a function of where we come from on the investment side, from Dimensional, and that sort of thought process around markets. But there's definitely some, almost for everybody, there's some training to get used to this idea that you're going to give your money and financial life to these professionals who don't actually like to do that much with your portfolio.
How Rubin Added $200M And 70 Clients In Three Years [12:06]
Michael: So I want to come back to the investment philosophy, investment side, in a moment, but I am surely curious. I think you said, when this was launching 3.5 years ago, it was $20 million getting started with a few clients. Now it's 200-plus and 80 clients. So where did $200 million and 70 clients come from in the span of 3 years? That's a lot of growth. That's basically two clients a month, clockwork all the way through. I'm sure it wasn't actually that smooth and even. But where did all the growth come from?
Rubin: I don't fancy myself to be that great of a businessman, but the two fantastic decisions I made were to figure out how to make the economics work with Rachael early on and then to figure out how to make the economics work with Emily after that. So I have hired incredibly talented people. Nobody in our team feels like a junior person, all sort of high-functioning people, which, if you look at a traditional three-person firm, a lot of time, it's kind of like one person at the top doing biz dev and blah, blah, blah, and some supporting staff are just kind of doing whatever the person at the top tells them, "This needs to be done to grow more." And we really don't operate like that.
So we kind of have what feels like three people who could almost all have their own firm. That's, from a financial perspective, obviously, cost me quite a bit, as far as they have to get compensated to want to work here. And so that also looks a little different, which is, I backloaded so much of what maybe a normal compensation might be for someone that manages a $240 million firm and thrilled to do it because it basically helped us get to where we are. So, incredible team internally to serve our clients.
The unique part about our growth, I would say, there's several bullet points, and they all kind of stand out to me. We've had an incredible referral network of COIs [Centers Of Influence], some of whom are also clients, but who knew either myself or myself and Rachael from our Dimensional days and who are no longer advisors or kind of adjacent to the industry, but sort of well-known sometimes. And so when they get asked questions about like, "Hey, will you manage my money?" or "Do you know anyone who should?" we get a lot of referrals that way from multiple kind of COIs. We've had a couple of Wall Street Journal articles with favorable mentions to us. And so that publicity usually gets a nice spike in larger clients. So that's been noticeable.
A couple of the things that come to mind would be I have a blog called Fortunes & Frictions, and that drives some traffic. It's very intentionally not trying to. I don't really say things like, "Hey, if you're not funding a 529 for your kids, you're missing out. Book a meeting with me here." I just kind of talk about whatever I want, but I found the feedback I've gotten over the years from people that reach out from, and it's like, "Hey, I've been reading you for a few years. It's authentic. I don't feel like you're selling at me, but I'm actually at the inflection point. I wouldn't mind chatting, and you kind of seem like my dude." So that's helped us.
And then the last thing I'd say that I've always kind of found has been a little bit unique about us is, of those 80 families, probably 15-ish come from my business school. I went to business school 2013 to '15. I went to a full-time school, full-time program. So pretty intimate with my classmates out in California. And so a lot of them work in tech, and they're kind of our target demographic and client. And having a LinkedIn presence where I'm top of mind for them has kind of become a great little flywheel for our firm. Where I am active is also where our target is, and a lot of that has sort of infiltrated my former classmates.
Michael: So I want to dig into each of these a little bit further, just to understand a little more context. So COIs that drive referrals for you, first, it sounds like you're not necessarily building on, "I've got this giant network of COIs who are all sending me a little bit of business." You've got a few kind of deep anchor relationships that are driving a lot of activity.
Rubin: Yeah, that's right.
Michael: How do those work? Where did that come from? How do the rest of us make this happen?
Rubin: Yeah, sure. I think an arc of our firm that's a little different than others is we were wholesalers before. So we kind of learned investment first and then had to teach ourselves planning. Most people go through CFP curriculum, and they learn planning, and then they find some fund companies they like doing business with. Maybe they pick up some things then. But they kind of learn investments after the planning. Or maybe don't think investments are super important, whatever it might be. For me, I and Rachael, we were wholesalers at Dimensional for a long time, so forged some really important relationships there.
The one that I can talk about publicly is with Dan Solin. Dan is one of my best friends and has been for many, many years now. I call him a mentor, but it just doesn't do justice. He really is. He means the world to me. And Dan really helped me launch the firm. Publicly, he's a client of the firm, so I can say that. He talks about that. And he is someone who is well known, New York Times bestselling author. And he's not an advisor anymore. So when somebody reads his book, which has happened, and they reach out to him and they say, "Hey, would you manage my money?" And he says, "I don't manage money anymore, but I can give you some referrals." Our firm is on that short list that he provides. And so that's a unique thing that obviously not everybody has access to, per se.
But I would say it is a very different approach than having 15 CPAs that I send cookies to every quarter and hope that we get some nibbles. Not that that can't work well, but for me, it's been, are there anchors from our friendship networks, maybe a little bit more purposeful relationships we have? And that is true for any advisor. What did you used to do? Where is your footprint where those people matter? And I would argue that those...doing that work, figuring out who's a really good COI that's uniquely mine as opposed to this network of CPAs and estate planning attorneys that the industry is so used to. What's unique about your past, where you know some people that might know some people that might want to be clients someday? And I would say, I think, what our firm has done is we've deeply nurtured those small amount of friendships, even if they're not traditional COIs. And that sort of worked really well for us.
Michael: And so the anchor point for you is we're not going after CPAs and accountants, and we're trying to find a select number of people that we can nurture more deeply with relationships.
Rubin: I wish it was that intentional. I feel like we fell backward into it. I think Rachael and I, we both care a lot about friendships and industry friendships. And so we were very careful with them to begin with. So they've lasted. I think, frankly, I would love if more CPAs and estate planning attorneys referred to us. It's just we're a three-person firm. There's only so many hours in the day. And it just frankly hasn't been how we do business. We don't think like that. It's like, "Hey, should we send cookies to 15 CPAs this quarter?" I bet you it would help. I don't think it would hurt, but it might have to be when we're a little bit bigger.
Generating Media Coverage Through Blogging [19:47]
Michael: And then you said part of this is some coverage in Wall Street Journal. So, where does Wall Street Journal coverage come from? How does that come about? Because that sounds lovely.
Rubin: It was lovely. Well, it's interesting. We've had two pieces. One, we were, I'd say, more prominently featured than the other. But we've been in there kind of twice, notably. And one was fantastic for business, and the other one didn't do anything. So the first one was Jason Zweig, who's just kind of a fan of the blog. And so he read a piece I wrote a couple of years ago. Every year, I write this annual kind of folly piece about Wall Street analysts forecasting their one-year return for the S&P 500. And I kind of make a mockery of that process. I don't think anyone should forecast the S&P over one year. But I've always been really interested because if I say that to a client and I say, "Isn't it crazy that people forecast where the market's going to go in one year?" every client is just going to nod and say, "Oh, my gosh, that does sound crazy. How would anyone know?"
But what always stood out to me was, if you dig a little bit deeper, there are some assets, like a one-year Treasury, where I can get you to the fourth decimal on my forecast, and I'm going to be right, because I know the yield for the next year on a one-year Treasury. So it's not just, "Isn't it so stupid that people forecast markets?" but it's like, "Which markets?" Because on some, you can actually get super precise, and on others, you shouldn't even try. And that's sort of what I write every year, is I say, "My forecast for the one-year Treasury is 4.2697%, and I'm going to be right. My forecast for the S&P is there's no stinking way I'm going to forecast that. That'd be crazy." And that sort of playful approach to it, I probably list 12 to 14 assets. Jason just likes it. And so, last year, at the end of the year, he sort of wrote a piece about it.
And why it worked, I think, more than the second piece that we had was because a lot of higher net worth people felt like they had found their voice in what Jason was saying our firm does, which has kind of peeled back the layers of how traditional Wall Street works. I'm thinking about a specific client who hired us, probably at that time, $8 million portfolio, they just had sort of a liquidity event. So it was kind of you could do whatever you wanted with the money too. And he reached out and said, "I've just been waiting for a voice like this because I talk to these advisors who are more investment-focused, stock picking on their value proposition in our initial meetings. And then they want me to pay them $80,000 a year for something that doesn't really resonate with me. And you saying that you don't forecast and that people are silly to try, you're my dude."
And so that piece, kind of, I wasn't very intentional in the interview with Jason as far as trying to do that. But thankfully, the topic sort of brought that out naturally. So that was great for business. We probably got three or four clients, a couple pretty large for us from that article. The next article...
Michael: Essentially just saying, I guess, some contrarian things, not saying the same stuff that everyone else says, because that's not as engaging for the media because they've heard it before. Interesting conversation when you…
Rubin: Exactly. Totally. And thankfully, it's Jason, who also has a different opinion than the traditional Wall Street motives. So it's not surprising to me he was interested in it.
Michael: And I'm presuming then this ties to the same theme of what you write on the blog. You're getting found by some of the media folks for writing on the blog in the first place. Tell us more about the blog and what gets discovered for all of us advisors out there who have had a company blog for years, and no one from The Wall Street Journal has ever called about our company blog. So, what are you doing? What are you writing about? What do you cover?
Rubin: So I would say I came from an institutional career at Dimensional. And it wouldn't be Dimensional only. It could be any fund company. But there's just heavy, heavy compliance for working at a fund company. If you want to work at a fund company, you can usually make a really nice salary, but you're not going to be able to have that much of a personality publicly about investing.
Michael: Right. Right.
Rubin: Get in line. There's a line there. And I had the good fortune at Dimensional to...part of my job was I would run study groups. And one of the study groups I ran was focused for advisors that had media presences. And so I got to meet all these fantastic characters, Taylor Schulte, Peter Lazaroff, Phil Huber, Roger Whitney, Kathy Longo, amazing people in their own right. But also, I saw having so much fun creating content. And actually Matt Hall, because he was probably the one I saw having the most fun creating content.
So when I left Dimensional, A, there was this opportunity to not have some of the burdensome compliance that comes around with working at a fund company, but also I had seen and now was kind of friends with the major advisors creating content in the industry. So when I launched the blog, there was some early advocacy for it from people like that. I can remember the specific time that Phil Huber tweeted it, and then Jason Zweig retweeted it, and then Barry Ritholtz retweeted it. And I was like, "Oh, my gosh, this is cool." So that was probably a step up I had, was I had some friendships and relationships that just wanted to like it for the sake that it was Rubin's, as opposed to even the content of it. However, the content itself has always been whatever kind of interests me at the time.
So I've written about bonds, and I've written about chess, and I've written about literature. I just write about whatever the heck I want. There's usually some tie to trade-offs. I think that's probably a common thread, is humans just don't realize enough that life is just trade-offs all the way down. And when you work at Dimensional, you learn very well to communicate that on the portfolio side. And then, when you become an advisor, a great advisor is going to learn to describe and discuss trade-offs on the life management and portfolio and financial planning side. And then, for me, I try to find things in life that are kind of hard, whether it's stories or ideas or little nuggets, and I mostly just talk about trade-offs. Even though people don't realize that, that's really the heartbeat of the blog.
Making The Economics Work For Key Early Hires [26:30]
Michael: So one other question I want to come back to that you mentioned earlier, and then I really do want to dig into the investment side. You said, as you're trying to hire up and expand early on, bringing on Rachael, bringing on Emily, and needing to figure out how to make economics work when we're earlier and we're still getting going with our own revenue, and then we're trying to hire a good team. Can you talk to us more about what you did?
Rubin: Yeah, it was hard. The first part, I'll start with Rachael. The first part is, can we get in the ballpark before we waste too much time toward a dead end? As I said, that is just, especially in our industry where people are talking all the time about mergers or takeovers or whatever, you don't want to waste too much time. Because people do this all the time, and it rarely works out. And so you want to make sure you're in the ballpark.
Then the second thing that I thought Rachael and I did a good job of was acknowledging the growth rate that, "Hey, there's a good likelihood this is going to work out if we can kind of put our nose down and work hard and serve clients well." But what are the levers that we have to pull on to make this palatable for Rachael to come accept some salary that is below a market rate for someone of her talent, and especially what she could go back and make at a place like Dimensional. And obviously, for that, the two big ones are going to be equity and variable comp to the upside. So what we talked about was base salary, then there's equity, then there's business development from her. There's a shared business development from anything Rubin does. And then we put out in the future a very large rock. And I said, "If we get to 200 million, I'll just cut you a check for 100 grand."
And those are the five levers we kind of pulled on. So base salary, equity, variable comp for her, for things she brings in, sharing variable comp for things that I bring in, and then other sort of variable comp in the future if we hit certain KPIs or milestones, where I can say, "Look, at that point, I think the firm will be making X amount of money, and it is so worth it to just cut a fat check to Rachael and embrace that we pulled it off."
Michael: So variable comp to biz dev for her is pretty straightforward. You bring in business, your income grows. Shared biz dev from you, I'm assuming that's along the lines of, "If you can take things off my plate and I can grow us more, that's still growing the firm. So I'll give you some incentives if I can grow more biz dev because of what you're helping with." So that's a shared bucket as well.
Rubin: Yeah. I'd say, I'm guessing, that's very non-traditional. But I would say Rachael is pretty non-traditional. This was a huge talent that she can come here. When we started, we paid ourselves $75,000 a year in year 1. And she could go make, what is it, $250 to $300 [thousand] at Dimensional, plus maybe. This is a huge, huge gap to bridge. And so I had to pull on all the levers I could to the point that I thought we could do it. And so one of them was, yeah, if we grow the firm, obviously, I own the firm. Until we talk about the equity part, I own all the firm at the moment. And that's an asset in my life. And so if I grow that, and I might not have liquidity, but I do have some additional wealth, and so that was something that I thought Rachael was a talent. I just saw a person I would love to be long-term partners with. And so it was something I was willing to forego to make it work. To bridge that large gap, I would have to do it for her to take a job like this.
Michael: So, can you give us at least a sense of, how did you start carving up biz dev? Is it a percentage of revenue? What kinds of percentages did you feel worked for the business of her portion or your shared portion? What kind of numbers did you get to that could work?
Rubin: It's over now. So one of the goals was this would get us started and get Rachael enough of the economics until we were a robust entity, and then we have to evolve. But I believe it was she would get 25% first-year revenue of anything she brings in. And then she was getting 15% of the revenue of anything I brought in for one year. And then I gave myself some buffer, as I have done for most things, where she's going to get a payout, or now Emily is going to get a payout as well, where I say, "Hey, I owe you this, but basically, I can pay it out over one year or two years or three years," sort of amortize it into the future just to not stress the firm liquidity.
Thankfully, one of the things I've sort of promised them always is, "When the firm can do it, I'm going to do it for you." So I've been able to, as we've had, I'd say, more success than I could have imagined, really, to this point. I didn't think we'd be this size right now. I have been able to just sort of say, "Hey, I know I have two years to pay you out, but I'm just going to cut you the check right now. And let's move on. And thanks for getting in the boat with me and growing this thing for three years." And it's worked out.
Michael: And just I hear there, the revenue incentives, that's for the year the revenue comes in? That's not permanent revenue share? Or did I mishear you?
Rubin: Yeah, yeah. No, no, you're right. It was a one-year revenue. We had this crazy spreadsheet where someone comes in. Let's say they're going to pay us $8,000 a year. So the first quarter, it's $2,000. And then Rachael is going to get 15% of that. And then I have...
Michael: Unless she brought it in, then she'll get 25% of that. So now there's a big spreadsheet of all the clients and all the payouts.
Rubin: I had 36 months to do it. We did it over three years for those. So we had this massively confusing spreadsheet, which had comically small numbers.
Michael: You gave yourself three years to pay it out just so you could smooth the cash flow because you're trying to run and grow the business while also sharing revenue out of the gate while you're trying to run and grow the business.
Rubin: Exactly. And then, when it kind of worked, I basically said to her, "I understand the time value of money, and this is valuable to me, but I would love to just not ever look at this spreadsheet again. So I'm paying you out, and let's move on."
Michael: There comes a point where the time value of money for the business is not worth the cost of the spreadsheet to maintain the calculation of the money spread out over three years.
Rubin: Yep, the money value of the spreadsheet.
Michael: Yeah. Yeah, yeah, the time value of the money exceeded the money value of the spreadsheet. But the anchoring is 15% to 25% rev share on first year's revenue paid out over up to 3 years, so we can smooth the cash flow of the business. And a "catch-up" payment if we get to $200 million of assets to help you bridge this further.
Rubin: Yep, yep. And I didn't take any rev, so I just paid myself that base salary this whole time.
Michael: Okay. Okay.
Rubin: Until recently, yeah.
Michael: And so, as you're building, you're getting a $75,000 base salary for a couple of years while you're building a million-dollar practice.
Rubin: Yeah. That's part of the trade-off. And it's one that I think more people...if they can stomach the illiquidity for a few years. I really wanted the people I wanted, and I really did not want turnover. So I wanted to give Rachael and Emily no reason to ever look elsewhere. And that costs money.
Michael: And then, to the extent you can share, how did the equity part work? That's often the hardest conversation for a lot of us, figuring that part out.
Rubin: Yeah. I'd say, in some way, I probably knew more about the ballpark than Rachael may even have, because when I left Dimensional, I did spend a year at another firm. So I've had these conversations myself before it made sense to launch my own firm. But what we aligned on was Rachael was going to be and she would become an equal, basically, decision-maker with me as far as firm decisions. So she's not legally on par, but she will...we are going to run this firm together, and we will introduce ourselves as business partners. And I am not her boss, per se.
However, she's not going to buy 50% of the firm yet. So we aligned on initial contract would be 15% of the firm that she could buy at a discount to an external valuation. But she'd be able to buy 15%. None of it was given, so she has to buy it, but at a very accommodating rate, and it would come in the form of 5% in 2026, 5% in 2028, and then it goes 5% in 2030.
Michael: Okay.
Rubin: With our growth, kind of as I said, I've had this philosophy I've sort of shared, I want to permeate the firm, which is, if we have success together, we're all going to share in it. So that turned into 15%. So that's where we started, and it got sweetened along the way through the last three years. And it turned into actually all 15% in 2026.
Michael: So, can you give us a little more context just how that worked or how the acceleration worked or what was triggering?
Rubin: We didn't really have a roadmap or expectations of assets and revenue growth. What I saw was a firm that was becoming of what I...it just seemed like a real business at one point. Maybe a year and a half or two years ago, I was like, "This is...I'm never going to work for anyone else again." That's kind of the thought I had. This is going to work, and I'm never going to work for someone else again, besides Rachael and Emily. So when that happened, and I see Rachael being Rachael and working so hard, serving clients well, clients love her, we are a fantastic duo together, just very complementary, I just felt like she was not a 5% owner in 2026. That didn't feel right.
Bluntly, I also had a really challenging personal experience since the firm launch. So in 2024 towards the middle of 2024, my ex-wife and I began the divorce process.
Michael: Oh, sorry.
Rubin: Yeah, thank you. And it was a hard one. And Rachael had to deal with that. When people go through that, it wasn't just hard for my ex and hard for me, but it's also hard for people that love us and are doing business with us and aligned to be a business partner with me. So, Rachael's efforts through that period, I think this sort of thing is hard to ever explain or communicate, but I needed a business partner who could understand what that process is like, especially I had a one-and-a-half-year-old kid when it started. And so I owe Rachael such a huge debt for giving me some of the grace and space I needed to go through that with my ex and make sure that both myself and my ex would figure it out and be okay on the other side and prioritize our daughter together and things like that.
And so there's something you can't quantify about what I put on Rachael's shoulders as someone who's been promised to become an equity owner. We're growing this business, and then my personal life is really stymied. And so I think some of that went into it, too, which is just I owe her so much. What can I do? Our firm's growing. We're having success. Why are we waiting till 2030 to finish this off? Let's get this first tranche done. I want to be partners forever. I hope she buys more.
Rachael's a little bit more spreadsheet-minded than I am, and so she always kind of teased me that I go off vibes a lot. But it really was. It was vibes, which I'm sure I can quantify that that was a ton of money that I didn't need to transfer to her. But it also gets her more motivated to work here and serve clients well and grow this with me. And we're not stopping at $235 million, right? We're going to grow and have a lot of fun together. And so I try not to think too much about the present value of dollars, given what our future together, I think, looks like as partners.
Michael: And financially, did you have to seller finance this? Is there a note and such, or were economics favorable enough that that wasn't necessary? I know, for some of these, it's also hard to make the cash flow work.
Rubin: Yeah. It actually hasn't gone...we haven't executed it yet because it's happening this year. But I do have my head around it and what's likely to happen. I think there's probably some seller financing on the table if she wants it. I don't think it'll be hugely necessary. It's not all off the 2026 numbers. So I sweetened the deal a little bit before that. So I actually gave a valuation. 5% is the 2024 end-of-year valuation, and 5% is the 2025 valuation, and 5% is the 2026 valuation. So the 2024 and 2025 tranches are kind of easy to take down because it's not a huge amount. The 2026 one, now, this is a real firm now, so that one's worth...
Michael: The numbers start getting bigger after a while.
Rubin: Yeah. Which is another thing we're going to have to deal with, right, which is I don't want it…neither of us wanted to stop at 15%. So the financing of it in the future is probably a harder thing. 2026 is a little bit challenging, but the first two are fantastic for everyone. But they're not that expensive for Rachael, and I'm thrilled about that because we did this together.
Rubin’s Investment Management Philosophy [40:45]
Michael: Right. So now help us understand what portfolios look like and I guess the investment philosophy, the investment management process at the firm.
Rubin: Yeah.
Michael: How is the $235 million invested?
Rubin: So Dimensional, as so many of your listeners will know, has this sort of cultish phenomenon and a fantastic fund company, fantastic investments. But also, let's be honest, fantastic marketing, like non-marketing marketing, right, they basically convince people that you should be using all of their funds. You are going to buy a philosophy instead of a mutual fund. And so if you buy into it, wouldn't you use 100% of the best stuff for your clients if you're a fiduciary?
Michael: Right.
Rubin: So many people, I'd say many advisors, operate that way. They use 100% Dimensional funds, and I think that's very justifiable given the long term track record of Dimensional. Rachael and I, or I'll speak for myself more, I'm more obsessed with the philosophy of, "Hey, markets probably work pretty well. So if you're going to pay someone higher fees to try to outperform the stock market, you better have a damn good reason why you're doing that." It's a little less fund company- or product-focused, but we're sort of, if you want to call it, rabid, efficient market people. But it's more just, does the world really work that way, where it's going to be that easy to just go pick a stock and outperform the market? I don't believe that it is.
So, on the equity side, we are, I would say, passive investors from a philosophical standpoint. We don't do any traditional security analysis when we tell clients what their stock portfolio is supposed to do. It's return the rate of the global stock market. We don't really have a home bias, and we basically communicate these principles that these prices are probably pretty fair out there, and it's not really worth our time to try to outguess them. We do incorporate some of the tilting that a place like Dimensional or like Avantis might do. I'd say those are the two fund companies we think most highly of. And so our portfolio looks a little bit different than just an index of the whole world. And we tell clients, over long periods, "We think some of these pursuit of higher expected returns through portfolio design and implementation, maybe we hope to add maybe 25 to 50 bps [basis points] a year over long periods, and you should expect sometimes to be super frustrated with us because you are going to underperform the number you'd see on the news that night."
On the bond side...
Michael: And this is a factor. This is value tilt.
Rubin: Yeah, exactly.
Michael: Are you specifically valuing small cap? Do you do some of the other factor tilts out there these days?
Rubin: We're big on the sort of economically intuitive ones, less behavioral ones. I want to make sure that if I put a client in something that I am going to have the confidence to stick with it if it underperforms for a while. So I'd say those three traditional ones of...Dimensional is kind of founded off of small and value, and then they added high relative profitability. I think the most intuitive ones are value and high relative profitability. So, value being two companies that are earning the same amount of revenue every year have the same profits. Can I pay a lower price for one of them? Or on the profitability side, two companies cost the same thing. Can I buy the one that makes more profits for the same price? Those are both very intuitive to me about why you should be able to pursue higher expected returns, small caps as well, but to a little bit lesser extent, in my opinion. Because it's an absolute measure as opposed to a relative one.
But yeah, I'd say those three traditional ones all make sense to me. I also know the data about how disappointing they can be if you go too far into it. So we like to integrate any factors that we're going to use. So portfolio is going to kind of tilt all three of those. We're less big on, A, certainly random factors or random noise someone might find in the data, but also things like momentum, which is a very robust factor, but also, in my opinion, could just go away one day. There's no reason why it has to exist, why stocks that have gone up recently should keep going up. And so I don't know if we have our favorites or whatever, but I would say we like ones that have some quantitative intuition or sensibility behind them.
Michael: Okay. So then help us understand more of, how do you frame this with clients? How do you talk them through getting comfortable with this framing and approach, getting comfortable with, "I'm paying you, Rubin, to buy me a largely passive index funds I could have bought myself?" Not always with DFA mutual funds, but functionally, they can do a lot of passive themselves. So just tell us more about how those investment conversations work with clients upfront and ongoing.
Rubin: When I launched the firm, I basically adopted the fee schedule I had from the firm I was at in between Peltoma and Dimensional. But ever since Rachael and I became partners, she was kind of encouraging a conversation like, "We should evolve this and separate the value proposition from planning and investment management, as opposed to one overall fee." And so, last year, we did that. And so we talk about these things separately, the value proposition on the investment side and the value proposition on the planning side. And so I think that's important about how we talk about...how we talk to clients about it. We separate them, and on the investment management side, I've had multiple clients over the three years who upload their statements, I look at them, and I tell them, "You are doing a fantastic job, and there's no reason that you need to hire us for investment management."
So you see someone that has all Vanguard portfolio, globally diversified, reasonable bond allocation. And I'm just like, "Hey, I don't want you to think you've done anything wrong here. I'm not going to tear this apart. It's a fantastic portfolio." So I would say we're very candid and honest on what we see. Where am I different from what we're going to do? And I have vivid memories of those conversations. But usually it doesn't happen. Usually, people come in with high fees I don't think they need to be paying. They don't understand their home bias. They have individual securities. They don't understand the likely distribution of outcomes when you own a single stock. They have various things that I think we can really improve upon for them. I think we have a very reasonable investment management fee, which starts at 50 basis points.
Michael: Okay.
Implementing A Flat Fee Plus AUM Fee Model [47:31]
Rubin: How we make that work is that we have a planning fee. And so we have three tiers of planning fees that basically vary in complexity. You're either an $8,000 client, $12,000 client, or $18,000-a-year client.
Michael: Okay.
Rubin: And that also covers $1 million managed. So there's a little bit of boost for the client end on that. But basically, you have these two fees. The first one's going to...the planning fee is going to include $1 million managed, and it's going to be 8, 12, or 18. And then everything above 1 million is at 50 bps. And then, actually, at 10 million, we give you another discount, and it's 25 bps above 10 million. But the economics of that reflect, I would say, some of our investment approach is…I'm happy to tell someone to go buy an ETF of the total market from Vanguard or Dimensional or Avantis, and I think that's a fantastic equity portfolio. So I'm not going to charge a buck and a quarter on it.
Michael: So I'm intrigued by this. So I want to make sure I understand. So the baseline is every client needs to pay the planning fee. The planning fee is 8k, 12k, or 18k. That covers up to $1 million managed if they so wish and desire for you to do so, I guess, or not. They can be planning only if their existing Vanguard portfolio is lovely and we don't have an issue with it. If and when and as assets grow, everything above 1 million does have an AUM fee, but we're already at a 50-basis-point breakpoint there, and it's 50 bps straight from 1 million to 10 million, discounts further if they're really big up there. That's the core structure.
Rubin: Yeah, two comments. I'd say, one, we do have some asset management-only clients. So they just pay 50 bps up to 10 million. So their first million is 50 bps. We don't have that many, maybe five or six, and that's fine for us. I think that's a fair fee for just managing a portfolio. I don't know if that's a great service, in my opinion, but we have people who want it. And so I have to basically be like, "All right, well, do you want it in a 60-40 or 70-30? Because I didn't do a financial plan for you. So I don't know. But if you trust that we do a good job with it, which we do, just tell me kind of what you want, or I can guide you a little bit based on your age, whatever." But I would say, for us, the heartbeat is the financial planning. That's what informs the portfolio. And then the way you describe the fee structure is right.
I'd say what's hidden that I would want advisors to know about in a structure like that is we get a lot of these high-performing, time-impoverished professionals. Let's say they're in their mid-30s, both spouses are working, young kids, and paying off medical school debt or something like that. And so let's say they have $700,000 to their name. Not a small amount of money either. But if, let's say, your advisor charges 1%, 7,000 bucks a year, is that worth it to deal with two super busy professionals and all the things you need to do for them for that year, whether it's making sure they're maxing out the 401(k)s, mega backdoor Roth 401(k)s, backdoor Roth IRAs, 529 plan, all of the things you're going to do for a family like this? To me, $7,000 does not seem like enough.
And so what we did was that financial planning fee allows us to integrate this idea of complexity that's not tied to an asset amount. And so a family like that at our firm is going to be $12,000, most likely, on the first million, right, if you think about it that way, because they're going to get their planning, and they're going to get $1 million managed. And so then, above that, it's 50 bps, but we get sort of, I would say, a fair market value from them from that $12,000 planning fee.
Michael: And then, what gets you to an $18,000 fee?
Rubin: We really try not to use it very often. I know the lifetime value of the family I just described. They're an incredible client if they hire Peltoma before they have $4 million or $5 million, and Goldman and Morgan Stanley and everyone has their claws on them. And so, thankfully, they're in a very similar life stage to myself or Rachael or maybe Emily. And so our firm kind of resonates with them. And I realize, if we serve the hell out of them, they're going to stay forever. And so, really, the 18 is used in very unique cases, if someone's highly, highly complicated. It's never really a goal of ours. I think, internally, we mostly think of 8 or 12 as our fees, but if we need it, we have 18. Because we don't have anything else.
One of the things why we got to this fee schedule was I had started to, early on, be open to negotiating. So if someone's like, "Hey, I don't want that, but can you do...? I don't want to pay your AUM fee schedule, but can I give you $14,000 flat or $17,000 flat?" As you know, when you start a business like this, you are open to whatever to get revenue in the door. And at one point, things just got too muddy for me, where there's a lot of interest in the firm, but I had people on too many different fee schedules.
Michael: Okay.
Rubin: And so what I did, what Rachael and I sort of aligned on, was we are not really making accommodations. You are either 8, 12, or 18 on the flat planning fee. And the 18 just allows us if someone really does come in super complicated and 12 isn't enough. We're not changing anything else. We're not going to jack 50 bps up to 75 bps or anything. We'll just reserve this ace in the hole for a really complicated case.
Michael: So, does that mean you converted prior existing clients into this structure to try to simplify down lots of accommodated fee schedules in the early days?
Rubin: We ran all the numbers about the impact of the evolved fee schedule on current clients, and for any clients that would get a discount, so some clients get charged less now, we moved it right away. And then there were two tiers of, for clients that have a small to moderate increase, we pushed it out one year till it actually occurred, and that hasn't happened yet. And so the end of this year, a large amount of clients will switch that have sort of modest but small-ish changes.
Michael: Our team has expanded. Our services have expanded. We do need to adjust our fees periodically. Here's the new number. That's usually a pretty straightforward conversation for most existing clients.
Rubin: It is. What I may look back someday and feel like I didn't do a great job on was this has not been positioned as a fee increase. And again, some clients got lower. For most, it's very similar. And for some, it's higher.
Michael: Okay.
Rubin: So, to round out that part, so at the end of 2027 is when the last clients will get on board, and those were the ones where it's the biggest jump upward on expectation. And we basically told people, "This isn't a fee increase. This is us sort of refining our philosophy around what's a fair way to pass in our value proposition." And the challenge to what you just said is that, at some point, I want to keep hiring talented people and expanding our scope of services and all that. And at some point, we may have to explicitly raise fees. And I think I've probably used a bullet here because I'm re-papering people to do this. And so, in my opinion, you don't want to re-paper people that often, even if clients are out working with a small increase.
Michael: Because new fee schedule means re-papering advisory agreement with new fee schedule.
Rubin: Exactly. Yeah, at our firm, I don't have the ability to just change it and tell people, "You don't have to sign."
Michael: Regulators have this weird issue with willy-nilly fee changes. Who knew?
Rubin: What's 25 bps to friends?
Michael: Yeah.
Rubin: So it's well documented from people like you that you can reasonably raise fees on clients if you provide a really good service, and usually, clients don't leave. But it's not a great experience, in my opinion, to re-paper people all the time.
Michael: No, no. I definitely would agree there. This doesn't feel great for clients. Yes, you can do it, but it doesn't feel great. We don't like to change our fee schedules often. We don't like to change firms and platforms often if we can help it. I find, for a lot of firms, if it's been a couple of years, it's usually fine, but re-papering clients twice in less than 12 to 24 months, they definitely notice. You may be okay, but they definitely notice. If it's been three-plus years, they're sort of like, "Oh, another one of these? All right. Explain to me what's going on. We'll talk through it."
Rubin: Yes. I would say this was not a fee raise, explicitly, although to some clients, it might feel like it. Their experience was like, "Oh, they're re-papering me, and my fees are going up a little bit." And so I don't think we can change fees again for a while. And so, if we do have expanded scope of services and I have a chance to bring in another really talented person, and that calls for money, I don't see the ability to pass that off onto clients anytime soon. But as long as markets keep going up 15% a year, I'll be fine, right?
Michael: Oh, absolutely.
Rubin: Yeah, sure, sure.
Michael: You can almost guarantee it, right?
Rubin: It's risk-free.
Michael: So, help us understand how you arrived at this structure. There's a planning fee, and the planning fee covers investments. Because even to the extent I see firms that have some kind of blended fee and offset, it tends to go the other way. It's like, "We have a planning fee, but once your assets are at a certain level, we waive the planning fee and just do the investments." Yours, to me, is the opposite. It's not the AUM subsumes the planning fee. At some point, it's the planning fee subsuming the assets for the first million, and you are only kicking in additional investment management for what's above a million. So just, I don't know, if you can give us a glimpse of what the internal conversations were with Rachael as you're going through this. Why this structure? How did you arrive at this? What were you trying to solve for with this?
Rubin: What we solved for was a philosophy of not having everything wrapped up into one AUM fee, which just we didn't like personally. We liked talking about our value propositions separately. And then we did run the numbers on, if we tried to make this similar to what clients are used to paying and have agreed is a fee where they would continue to pay us, how can we make it somewhat similar? And so we looked at, should a flat fee cover the first 500 grand or 1 million or 1.5 million? So we did all numbers like this.
Michael: Okay.
Rubin: And also, should it cover nothing? Should it be separate? Whatever it might be. But there was some in...I don't know if it's the best way to do it, but there was this idea of let's not jack things one way or the other. If we can find something that feels reasonable and sounds reasonable, and it's kind of close to what we're doing, that'd be great. Again, from optimizing on the economics of the firm, I probably underdeliver on that because we probably could raise fees quite a bit. We probably could raise fees instead of just kind of changing fees, but it wasn't the goal of this exercise.
Michael: Okay.
Rubin: Where I think it's really...
Michael: I think, functionally, you have no investment minimum now because it doesn't matter.
Rubin: Exactly, exactly.
Michael: You engage with the planning if you value the planning, and then the assets come on top, and we don't even have to worry about this for the first million.
Rubin: Yeah. Where I think, on both sides of this barbell that I talk about, which is these high-performing professionals who are just kind of busy and growing their families and careers and all that and might have 700 grand, and this higher-end client we have. Some of them might have $7 million to $10 million with us, who tend to be, again, a little bit older. I think it works well for both of them. So, on the front end, the former, we are able to get, call it, 120 basis points on the first million, even if they don't have a million with us. So I think we made the economics of a relationship like that where we do a ton of work for someone if they don't have a lot of assets. That works for us, primarily driven by the flat fee element.
Then, for a client that might have $7 million to $10 million with us, you see that they look at 50 basis points, and they're like, "That's really fair. That guy could squeeze just a buck and a half," or whatever it might be.
Michael: And I guess, ironically, at that point, yeah, there's also an $8,000 or $12,000 planning fee layer, but that's much smaller than the AUM portion. So they're not as stressed. But your AUM portion is already 50 bps, which looks competitive or better to some others that they talk to. So just the big clients don't really worry or haggle about the planning fee much because the AUM fee already seems reasonable on 7-plus million? Am I processing that right? How does that show up?
Rubin: Yeah, yeah. The impact of the planning fee on your overall aggregate expense of our firm is obviously lower. I think, to go off a little bit here would be, also, we've evolved, in my opinion. This industry has evolved. There's a lot of firms that look like ours who don't have fancy office space. The software we use is so much better than it was one year ago, five years ago, and certainly ten years ago. We have become a better, more efficient industry, if you want it. And we have leaned so far into that, mostly driven by Rachael and Emily, who I have about 10 years on Rachael and maybe 15 years on Emily. They are at a, noticeably to me, different technological generation, and they're dialed in the way that our firm operates our systems. And to me, asset management isn't worth 1.5%, just like I don't think markets work like that, where you can justify a fee like that.
And so I think it's a very reasonable fee. I think you can still run a fantastic advisory firm. And for us, it did take that flat planning fee to ensure we can still run a robust business, but I think 50 basis points works very well. And the one thing you'll notice about it that helps us too is it's supposed to be simple, but it also does go all the way to 10 million. And so even for firms that might start at 1.5%, oftentimes, by the time you're at 8 million, 9 million, 10 million, they might be where we are. They might already be down to 50 basis points.
Michael: Right. So you converged on other firms as you grow, as it moves up.
Rubin: Right. And so, if we can get these people in, I know where we're good at, which is retention and having people feel loved on and served well. And so if I can get you to 8 million at 50 bps each and you're going to stick with us for the next 20 years, yeah, it's a heck of a client.
Peltoma’s Client Service Model [1:02:39]
Michael: And so, now, help us understand more of what the ongoing side of, I guess, investment service model engagement looks like. How often do you meet with clients? How much are you talking portfolios versus planning? What does this look like for ongoing clients as you've built out?
Rubin: So one thing we're big on is we have a guiding principle to our firm, which is never surprise clients. So we have authority over accounts. I can technically trade whatever I want to trade for clients. But we tell them that, "You're going to know what's going on in your portfolio, at least at a high level, and even if you don't care." We want you to have a basic understanding of what's going on, and the way that we implement that is...so we have an onboarding process, where we are kind of training clients how we do things. But twice a year, we review their portfolio for them, and that process is, basically, I shoot a video on how the market did, how their portfolio did, and then I explain any differences. That happens midyear. So that midyear review, so six months into year, that happens just by video.
So I scale out a market review, one market review, and then I shoot 80 portfolio reviews. And then you, as a client, receive the first part, just like everyone else, and then your going bespoke second part. But to you, it's just one video.
Michael: And you or someone splices them together...
Rubin: Exactly.
Michael: ...and make it one video.
Rubin: So we use Loom, and we splice it.
Michael: Okay.
Rubin: We do that twice. So that's the midyear review. We do an annual planning meeting with every family in Q1. And so, there, we actually give clients a choice, and we say, "We need you to meet for the annual planning meeting." You can either do a one-hour annual planning meeting, which is going to be driven by Rachael and Emily, focused on the plan, what we're going to accomplish this year, a checklist for us, a checklist for you, make sure that we're capable of what we said we would do for you, or you can make it a 90-minute meeting, and you can do all that, plus 30 minutes of investments with Rubin. And if you choose not to do the 90-minute, then I'll shoot you a video as well so you have it.
Michael: Oh, interesting. So they basically got the choice of, do I want the longer conversation with investments with Rubin, I guess, synchronously, live, or the async version with video?
Rubin: You got it. Yeah. I think where my friends in the industry are like, "You're freaking crazy, dude," is the midyear review takes a lot of time, because Rachael and Emily also shoot a financial planning video for everyone.
Michael: Okay.
Rubin: And so we have this client roadmap that includes these touchpoints in the middle of the year, which takes a lot of time and resources from the three of us, but we also have a link in our signature where clients can meet with us anytime.
Michael: Okay.
Rubin: And more likely, if a consultant looked in our business, they would say, "Hey, if you're going to have a link in your email that says, 'If clients ever want to meet with you, they can,' you probably need to invest less resources in going overboard on all this stuff. If they have questions, they'll reach out."
Michael: Or they'll reach out more with questions, and you're preempting question meetings by proactively putting up videos.
Rubin: Yep. Yeah.
Michael: How often do clients end up scheduling meetings through the year? I guess, are there any other meetings? Or nominally, if I like the videos and I'm reasonably video engaged, I do the beginning of your planning meeting, and that might be my only meeting for the year if I didn't have other stuff that I wanted to engage with you on. Are there other meetings or engagement points as part of the service calendar?
Rubin: There are touchpoints. I shoot a market video as well for at the end of every quarter, but I don't tie it to your own portfolio. So it's just one broad market review with Rachael and I.
Michael: Like a quarterly market thing?
Rubin: Yeah, exactly. So you'll get that. Again, if you feel confident enough from these touchpoints, then you won't reach out a lot, which is great for us, knowing our time. But no, there aren't any other formal times that we tell clients, "We really need to meet with you." We have our own internal things, which is, "Hey, in October, let's make sure people who said they're going to max out their 401(k) have done it this year." So we may have to reach out to you, but we don't have any other formal touchpoint. We really highlight that we want to meet you where you're at, on how you want to engage with us, but we really do ask for that Q1 meeting to set the roadmap for the year.
Michael: And so, truly, internally, you've got a huge burst of meetings in Q1 because that's the annual meeting for all the clients. And then it's a little lighter or more even through the year because your touchpoints are on your own schedule. And clients may schedule periodically, but it's certainly not all of them at once, the way that it is in Q1.
Rubin: Yeah. So it's a Q1 surge, if you will, and it certainly feels like that. We're slammed. Our business development goes down that quarter. It's very noticeable how much that takes on the firm. But then, after that, yeah, and a lot of our clients who are already super busy and feel loved on, we don't often hear from a lot of people for a while. Again, I think that we've been very fortunate that, since the firm launched, we've had really accommodating markets. We've had the tariff tantrum and then issues in the Middle East. So April 2025, March to April 2025, March to April 2026. But other than those kind of quick downturns and rally-backs, we haven't had to answer a lot of investment questions.
Maybe we'll get there this year on fixed income, but it hasn't taken that much energy. And so, if clients feel good about their plan, see their portfolio going up, it's been a few great years as far as not having to spend too much time on investments.
Using Videos To Communicate Planning And Portfolio Updates To Clients Asynchronously [1:08:56]
Michael: So talk to us a little bit more about the videos. How do you set this up? How does it work? How long does it take you to do each video times all the clients? Walk us through this.
Rubin: It was a tough one for us this summer. I was at a period in my life coming out of divorce where I was...I spent the summer in Montana, and I just wanted to hang out with my siblings and parents and not think about work. It's like, "I needed a break." Rachael and Emily had shot a lot of their video content already right after the quarter ended, so right after Q2 ended, and they'd shot their sort of financial planning video. And for some clients, I was two, three weeks behind them on getting to my videos. And it caused some issues when, in the middle of it, the client would reach out maybe two weeks after Rachael and Emily had shot their video, but I hadn't shot mine yet. And the client would say, "Hey, this happened in my life. Can you change my financial planning? Let's talk about it." And Rachael and Emily are like, "Well, shoot. Now my video goes to waste because Rubin hadn't shot his investment video yet. We didn't get it to them yet. And now I got to go change it all." And so it's stale.
Michael: Because you splice all of the videos together. So if they do their planning part and you haven't done your investment part yet, then they have to redo their planning one.
Rubin: Yeah. So that was a great learning lesson for us, which is not just that Rachael and Emily are more on top of their stuff than Rubin is. But this coordination of our various expertises or whatever, trying to tie all into one spliced video for a client, you really have to be dialed on the timing of it all if you want to get the fruits of scale. And we can do it. We just had not really aligned on how the summer was going to look. It usually is a period where we all take a little time off. And we've gone from, in 2025, last summer, maybe it was 50 families, and then this summer, it was 75. And so it's also a different beast because we have the same amount of employees.
So it's a great learning lesson, which is, if you want to try to do something like that, you really have to coordinate and map out the timeline of how you're going to accomplish and deliver. And small hiccups can lead to sort of bigger issues. And internally, I would be frustrated if I were Rachael and Emily because you're like, "Gosh, I just kind of wasted my time shooting this video because now it's stale, and Rubin didn't deliver on his part in time." So that was, again, a great learning lesson for us, but that's how, if you want to scale with video, I think it's fantastic to share duties, but just collaborate on how it's going to get done.
Michael: I guess, just walk me through what video looks like for you, though. Is there a day that's video day, and you sit down and do 50 ten-minute videos for 8 hours straight? How does it work? How do you produce these? What is the process when you got to sit down and go through them all?
Rubin: Yeah. I'm happy to share the market review one too if you want from Q2, but obviously, that's the scale one that has no client names. When it's getting delivered to a client, it'll have that first snip of the market review. Then we use Orion. So I download a performance report for the first two quarters in Orion. And Loom, basically, your head is kind of in the corner, and you're talking through a page on a screen to somebody. And so I basically say, "As you saw in the last video, the stock market in the U.S. did 10%. Stocks outside the U.S. did 17%. And then the bond market was fairly muted 0% to 1% returns. Here is your portfolio. As you know, we're a 65% equity target with a 35% bond target. We've moved a lot of our bonds into short-term bonds because you're going to buy a house soon. And those actually did really well last quarter because those are more reliable returns. It's really traditional bonds that are more muted. So you got a little boost from that and the overall bonds because you overweighted short-term bonds. That's random. That's not our expertise."
But the idea would be, "Here's how your 65-35 did. Here's how a market-based 65-35 did or a relevant benchmark." And then I'll say, "Hey, you underperformed by 2%, and I want to explain to you why that is. It's because we overweighted small caps, and those didn't do well. And you also used to work at Meta, and 200 grand of your million-dollar portfolio is still in Meta stock with a low cost basis, and Meta did really crappy these last two quarters." I would say it's a high-level attribution analysis where I give you the bullet points of why you're different and how it impacts it. And then I offer up to people, "If you really want to get granular, I'm happy to do that with you. But those are the bullet points of why you look different than the market."
Michael: How long is a video?
Rubin: So the market review is somewhere between three to ten minutes. Anytime we shoot one of those, depending on what we're doing. And then a client video is anywhere between, I'd say, 3 and 15 minutes.
Michael: Okay.
Rubin: That's my investment portion. Then Rachael and Emily's portion might be upwards of another 30 to 40. So some of the client videos this year were 45 to 60 minutes.
Michael: Okay. And interesting. That part, you're almost just at the length of a meeting. You cut out the client to do a meeting. You're simply doing an asynchronous meeting on your own time. I guess I hear that, and I'm like, that doesn't feel like it's super time-consuming. It's just you are turning the time you otherwise would spend in in-person meetings into asynchronous meetings because you've got busy clients who are hard to pin down for meetings, I'm guessing. So they actually probably consider this a positive service. "Thank you, Rubin, for not making me put this on my calendar because I'm so busy. I'll just watch it on my own time to the extent I want to click through."
Rubin: Yeah. I would say the challenge is I know it sounds kind of silly, and yet, what is the benefit to people like this of just doing it async and this sort of qualitative idea of, "Do they walk away being like, 'Gosh, that's great. They didn't make me do a meeting on this?'" Maybe, but I also know a bunch of them don't watch it. And that's fine.
Michael: So, when you do these, do you batch them? Do you do a stack of them in a day and grind through them in a week or two, or do you spread them out more? How does that work when you've got 80 of these to get through?
Rubin: It took me three weeks.
Michael: Okay.
Rubin: Some days are more productive than others. Some clients are simpler than others. But yeah, the goal would be approaching this again next summer. If we do it, it should feel very similar to surge. It's just, instead of a client coming in, it's a video you got to shoot. You want to bang them out.
Michael: I was going to say it reminds me a lot of surge. For advisors that do surge, frankly, most advisors I know that do surge with 80 clients take more than 3 weeks. We're not most of us. So even if we surge, we're not doing 25 to 30 client meetings a week through surge. To get through 80 clients in 3 weeks, it takes longer than that. So, to me, you describe a more efficient surge process to the extent that most clients say, "This is great, and I don't need a meeting." If they do this and then they all want meetings, you've added work to a meeting, and that at least gets a little harder to figure out whether this is efficiency for the firm or a value-add that's worth it even though it takes more time. But just relative to so many of us that do two client meetings a year or more, what you're describing still sounds like a lot of time savings to me. It's not no time.
Rubin: I agree. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Totally agree.
Michael: All my midyear client meetings done in three weeks sounds lovely.
Rubin: And I will say we do have data on who wants to meet after we've sent out the videos. So we're now almost three months to the end of the quarter. These have probably been out for four to six weeks at this point, and hardly anyone wants to meet.
Michael: Hardly anyone, meaning 10 or 20 clients or 2 or 3?
Rubin: Oh, no, less than ten. Yeah, yeah, well less than ten.
Michael: Okay. Okay.
Rubin: So I would say, again, some of them haven't watched it or haven't watched it yet. Others get what they need from it. And absolutely, we are living in the world of efficiency because it's all digital. Rachael's shooting. She lives in the summer in Park City. She's shooting her videos there. Emily was in North Carolina. I was in Montana. It's incredible. It's a great setup because we can do it on our own time without having a schedule of clients when they're going to come into an office that we don't have. So it's relatively efficient. But as far as within the world of being efficient, I would say we have a lot of improvement that we can make. Because this summer, we had a lot of learning lessons about the collaboration of it all.
What Surprised Rubin The Most Building His Advisory Business [1:17:50]
Michael: So, as you look at this journey as a whole, what surprised you the most about the path of building an advisory firm? You saw it from the other side for so many years as a wholesaler. What surprised you the most being in the seat and building it yourself?
Rubin: Well, for those of us that have been around this industry for long enough, I'd say we kind of realize that it's the best job in the world. Where else do you get to look behind the curtains of people's lives, make a difference, have someone look you in the eye, and say, "I don't know where I'd be without you," but also have none of the risk of doing brain surgery or something, right? This is just the best job ever, in my opinion. And what surprised me about it is how few people have this opportunity to design the firm that they want and don't. And for me, I have a firm that I want. I know what it's cost me, which was a lot of the economics early on.
And for me, what surprised me is I thought I would care about that, but I don't care at all. We are having such a great time serving people well, and the economics come eventually for me at some point down the road. And so I have minimal to no regrets about the way we launched this firm, which was a huge investment in the people here. And I'm surprised at how many firms, knowing bluntly how lucrative these firms are at the end and where you're going, aren't willing to make those sacrifices early on to avoid things like turnover and to have things like highly talented people dealing with clients.
Michael: So talk to us more. How did you get comfortable with the size of the income step backwards to get to this?
Rubin: Yeah. It was actually two-pronged. I launched the firm with some clients that I had worked for at the old firm. And I think it was probably, I don't know, maybe a little bit over $100,000 in revenue, which, as we know, doesn't...you have a lot of expenses to get going and, for me, serve people the way they were used to being served previously at a more robust firm. So it's not like I got to take that home, but I remember that I had in my...I did pay myself for a few months, and then, when I was finally starting to pay myself, it was $100,000 a year. And then, immediately, when Rachael and I started having conversations, I moved it down to 75 because I was like, "I can't justify that anymore." And so, in fact, Rachael and I both started saying that.
So personally, at the time I launched the firm, I was still married. My now ex, she had a nice job at the time. I was 38 or 39. I had worked for a while. I had saved. So there were some savings to use. And I knew that I had this sort of golden opportunity because I'm not naturally entrepreneurial. I would have never gone and launched a firm from Dimensional. I'm not a natural entrepreneur.
So, for me, I did have the buffer, but also, I didn't realize that starting with some clients is way, way different than starting with zero clients. And that opportunity that I had sort of got me over the threshold to justify bleeding into savings, convincing my wife at the time that it was worth it for the long run, and things like that. But it wasn't easy for me, but certainly harder for Rachael when we decided to do it because she has more options. The firm isn't hers to start. And so, for me, at least, I knew I was growing this asset.
The Low Point On Rubin’s Journey [1:21:37]
Michael: So, what was the low point for you on the launch and build journey here?
Rubin: Absolutely, the answer would just be the personal side of what I went through during this time. There's only so many hours in the day and energy we have. And all of us who have friends who have been through a divorce or have personally been through a divorce, it can be a very challenging period, again, to look out for your spouse, or to be a former spouse, to look after yourself, for us to look out for our kid and manage through gracefully. And so, for me, we had just come out of COVID. I just started a company. Rachael and I had just partnered together. I was a new dad. I have my own personal preferences. I wanted to hang out with my parents and my siblings and my friends. And then you have a failed marriage that you're trying to wrap your head around what happened. This is what we thought would happen. How do we push through this?
And so, whenever I'm around advisors, people always are like, "Let's talk shop. Let's step out of the business to work on the business." But for me, my biggest challenge, the low point, has been trying to disentangle…well, it's over now, but was trying to disentangle the stress from my personal life with the stresses of being a new business owner and my business life. You can't build, essentially, close to from scratch and not have completely intertwined personal and professional lives for some period. And so you get all the successes and stressors from both of them from the other one. And so I just kind of forced myself through many days at work where I'm trying to grow this company on my professional side, but what I really need are personal days, where I don't have to think about work.
Michael: I was going to say, in practice, what was the stress management approach, the coping strategy? How did you handle through? It sounds like taking personal days became a thing.
Rubin: Yeah. I would say that's what I needed. I'm not saying we don't really... I'm always sort of on. I'm aware. It's a young business. I'm an entrepreneur. It's hard to check out entirely. But Rachael really stepped up and not necessarily knew the nuances of the challenges I was going through, but knew probably what I was going through and stepped in. And she's a very special advisor. I'd say a lot of these, as I shared earlier, a lot of our clients are some of my best friends in life, but she has seamlessly stepped in where they're as comfortable with her as they are with me. And as I shared earlier, just forever grateful that I have a business partner that also sort of sees the long game, knows that we're both going to go through hard periods in our life since we're long-term partners together. And certainly, at this point, I'm the one that's indebted to her.
Rubin’s Advice For His Younger Self And For Newer Advisors [1:24:33]
Michael: So now that you're many years into this, I'm curious if there are other pearls of wisdom from experience. What do you know now you wish you could go back and tell you from a couple of years ago, as you were transitioning out of DFA and trying to figure out what might come next?
Rubin: I think coming out of DFA, the defining part of that is my personality wasn't built for DFA. I'm pointy, and I have strong opinions about things, and I like talking about them. And so, me being radically authentic on LinkedIn, that's me not going into the advisor's office trying to sell them mutual funds and saying whatever they want to hear. So the defining moment, the defining part of that, was just I kind of finally got to be myself. And I think, for a lot of people working in a place like Dimensional, which was a fantastic job for me, probably more people should be interested in jobs like that, because for a lot of people, they don't really want to talk about their pointy opinions or spray the internet with weird things that are going through their mind. They want to have a nice paying job where they feel like they're doing good work and get home to their family and go to the kids' soccer games, and things like that.
And gosh, being a wholesaler is a heck of a gig for something like that. You can make really good money and have a lot of stability. And so it was an inflection point where I sort of learned this was a sweet run. I love working at DFA, but it couldn't have been a long-term home for me, because I'm just not a long-term wholesaler. But I love, as I said earlier, trade-offs all the way down. And there are so many parts of a job like that, but I think newer generation of people really overlook some of the benefits of the stability and time that a job like that can provide as opposed to going off and be a cowboy entrepreneur.
Michael: So, then, any other advice you would give younger, newer advisors looking to build their own firms and get launched in today's world?
Rubin: Yeah. I would say two things. One is you do not want to hire your personality out. So I see so much on the Internet of people paying third parties to post market opinions or whatever it might be. You do not want to go that route. When people hire us, they say things like, "I just kind of like how you guys are yourselves online." So you want to be your radical self, whether it's your footprint to do that online or whether it's just in meetings. But as an advisor, you really do have the ability to embrace your personality rather than hide it. And that's a benefit of this industry that people should lean into.
What Success Means To Rubin [1:27:23]
Michael: So, as we come to the end here, this is a podcast about success, and just one of the themes that always comes up is that that word success means different things to different people. It changes for us through career and stages of life sometimes. And so you're on this wonderful growth trajectory with the business, as you've crossed $1 million of revenue in barely 3 years. The business seems to be in a wonderful place now. How do you define success for yourself at this point?
Rubin: The firm is named Peltoma, which is named after this lake in eastern Canada, where there was this interaction 400 years ago, where these Frenchmen arrived to sort of take over the land and pillage through the villages of the natives, and there's this interaction between this native tribe, the Mi'kmaq and these Frenchmen. And it's basically the natives questioning that that really is how you should live life. That going to try to find gold and treasures and be away from your family for months at a time while they're back in Europe, is that really what being wealthy is? And this tribe, the Mi'kmaq tribe, the interaction, basically, the dialogue was they said to...this guy, Pierre Biard, who's now a French, he said, "You think you're rich, but you're not rich. You have material assets. We can see that. But we have greater assets. Ease, comfort, and time."
And that's what we tell clients. That's why the firm is named Peltoma. Ease, comfort, and time is what wealth means to how we work with clients and what we're trying to deliver to them. It's what their money is the tool for. I certainly embrace that. The coolest part of my job is I'm going to walk my daughter all the way to school whenever the hell I want. That is not something everyone gets to say. And so that is so meaningful to me.
The point I want to get to as far as success, besides this broad ease, comfort, and time for us and our clients, is I feel so strongly that this industry has done many things backward for a long time. That's what I dedicate a lot of my efforts online to talking about, is peeling back the layers of how Wall Street traditionally acts and how I think Wall Street and money management should act. And if I can get to a point in my career where my clients can say, "That guy took the privilege of managing my money the right way. He never squeezed us. He never discomforted us. He never pulled the wool over our eyes. He managed money the right way and gracefully ran a firm where he shared the fruits of the financial success that we had and, therefore, that he had with his colleagues," then that would be the most successful moment I could imagine having in my career.
Michael: I love that. I love that. It's very much the foundation of we can do well by doing good.
Rubin: It's the best job in the world.
Michael: They can coexist. I love it. I love it. Well, thank you so much, Rubin, for joining us on the "Financial Advisor Success" podcast.
Rubin: It's a huge pleasure. Thank you, Michael.
Michael: Thank you.



