May 2008 issue of The Kitces Report on The Impact of Market Valuation on Safe Withdrawal Rates
May 2008 Issue of The Kitces Report
Enjoy the current installment of "Weekend Reading For Financial Planners"– this week's edition kicks off with the news that a recent analysis from Morningstar suggests that the Department of Labor's (DoL's) new Retirement Security Rule (aka Fiduciary Rule 2.0) could save retirement plan participants $55 billion over the next 10 years (due to an expectation of more low-cost fees being offered in plans) and those rolling over workplace plans into IRAs to purchase annuities another $32.5 billion (thanks to expected reductions in commissions and the embedded costs in these annuities). Nonetheless, for these potential benefits to come to pass, the rule will likely have to survive legal challenges, including a lawsuit filed led by an insurance industry lobbying group seeking to halt implementation of the rule (which is set to take effect in September), which argues that the rule violates the U.S. Congress' intent in passing ERISA and that the DoL overstepped its authority in adopting it.
Also in industry news this week:
- The latest Social Security trustees report offered a slightly rosier picture for the health of the various Social Security trust funds thanks to improved economic conditions, though they warned that time is running out for legislators to take action to ensure the system will be able to pay out full benefits beyond the early 2030s
- RIA custodian Altruist has raised $169 million in its latest funding round, giving it a $1.5 billion valuation and added capital to fund technology and staffing upgrades as it seeks to challenge Schwab and Fidelity in the RIA custodial space
From there, we have several articles on retirement planning:
- Why considering a client's retirement time horizon and spending flexibility could lead to more accurate (and often higher) safe withdrawal rates than the simpler "4% rule"
- While many financial advisors focus on preventing clients from depleting their portfolios in retirement, they might be overlooking the 'risk' that clients might underspend and not achieve their retirement lifestyle goals
- How the creator of the "4% rule" is now incorporating inflation and equity valuations when calculating safe withdrawal rates
We also have a number of articles on advisor marketing:
- A 4-step process that can help financial advisors craft better stories to use with clients
- The best and worst times to use emotional storytelling to communicate an important message to clients
- How effective storytelling can increase the likelihood that an advisor's message will resonate with clients amidst a sea of potential information sources
We wrap up with 3 final articles, all about vacations:
- How taking a vacation can provide a sense of clarity that can lead to positive changes in one's 'normal' routine
- How to decide how much to spend on a vacation, from planning out a year's worth of trips in advance to being aware of "luxury creep'"
- Why money spent on vacations and other shared experiences could be considered an investment in an appreciating asset
Enjoy the 'light' reading!
Enjoy the current installment of "Weekend Reading For Financial Planners" - this week’s edition kicks off with the news that the House Financial Services Committee unanimously passed a bill that would direct the SEC to conduct a study and carry out a rulemaking on the definition of a "small entity" to reduce the compliance burden on small businesses, presumably including RIAs.
Also in industry news this week:
- Legislation working its way through Congress would allow for electronic delivery of documents to clients of advisors and other financial services firms by default, though it has been met with some opposition
- While RIAs have outpaced wirehouses in terms of client asset growth and headcount, industry consolidation has led to a decline in the number of RIAs, according to a study from Cerulli Associates
From there, we have several articles on practice management:
- Why serving 'non-ideal' clients is seen as the top productivity challenge for advisors, according to one survey
- How putting in the extra time to practice ahead of client meetings or seminars can pay off for advisors
- Why stressed-out firm owners might consider downsizing their client base rather than selling their firm
We also have a number of articles on investments:
- While tax-adjusting a client’s portfolio can be a valuable service, doing so accurately can be challenging
- The potential benefits and risks of investing in funds that engage in securities lending
- Why holding on to stocks, rather than moving to cash, could be a smart move, even if a recession is expected to occur
We wrap up with 3 final articles, all about technology:
- Why LinkedIn could be a valuable 'one-stop shop' for social media users
- How ChatGPT and other AI tools have come under fire for using published content on the Internet to train their models
- How 'passkey' technology introduced by Google and other web services could lead to the end of passwords
Enjoy the 'light' reading!
Welcome to the May 2023 issue of the Latest News in Financial #AdvisorTech – where we look at the big news, announcements, and underlying trends and developments that are emerging in the world of technology solutions for financial advisors!
This month's edition kicks off with the news that robo-advisor Betterment entered into a $9M settlement with the SEC for misrepresenting its tax-loss harvesting practices in its client agreements and marketing materials compared with its actual practices (e.g., 'only' checking client portfolios for tax-loss harvesting every other day, after having advertised daily checks) – a first for the SEC in scrutinizing an RIA not for failing to execute its investment promises to clients, but for failing to execute tax-loss harvesting promises instead. Which may raise questions for other RIAs (including smaller firms) who promote their tax-loss harvesting practices as part of a 'tax-efficient' investing strategy about whether their own practices (and the technology they use to implement it) really align with what they claim to provide.
From there, the latest highlights also feature a number of other interesting advisor technology announcements, including:
- Altruist has announced a $112 million Series D fundraising round to expand its capabilities to meet the needs of larger advisory firms, the latest in a series of high-profile moves (including becoming a fully self-clearing broker-dealer and acquiring its rival custodian SSG) positioning Altruist to compete directly with the likes of Schwab and Fidelity for established RIAs.
- GeoWealth has acquired its fellow TAMP First Ascent Asset Management, marrying GeoWealth’s tech-forward, open-architecture investment management platform with First Ascent’s 'concierge'-style investment and service-oriented solution (and its flat-fee TAMP business model).
- T. Rowe Price has acquired Retiree Income, the parent company of popular retirement income planning software SSAnalyzer and Income Solver, to put its resources behind developing and distributing the company’s planning tools (albeit perhaps more to its retail and employee retirement plan clients than to advisors?).
Read the analysis about these announcements in this month's column, and a discussion of more trends in advisor technology, including:
- Business support software provider Benjamin shuts down its operations, which may say less about the demand for workflow support tools (which appears to remain strong) and more about Benjamin's positioning itself as an "AI-driven digital assistant" in an environment where advisors may not trust AI technology enough to pay for it as a solution.
- A look back at the evolution of advisor technology as we come up on the 5-year anniversary of our Financial AdvisorTech Solutions Map, which reflects not only the increasingly crowded landscape with a proliferating number of solutions on the market, but also how shifting technology needs of advisors themselves are eliminating whole categories of advisor technology… and spawning new ones as well.
And be certain to read to the end, where we have provided an update to our popular "Financial AdvisorTech Solutions Map" (and also added the changes to our AdvisorTech Directory) as well!
*And for #AdvisorTech companies who want to submit their tech announcements for consideration in future issues, please submit to [email protected]!
Enjoy the current installment of "weekend reading for financial planners" – this week's edition kicks off with an interesting investor research study showing what clients are actually interested in learning and hearing about now... which shows that while there was an initial burst of interest in commentary about markets and the economy, within just a week or two of the pandemic shutdown client interest had already shifted to topics more 'personally' relevant to them, from health and wellness to thinking about second careers (as the pandemic may have shut down their first!), and the family dynamics of how the pandemic and its economic impact may be rippling through their personal lives beyond their portfolios alone.
From there, we have several practice management articles on the continued adaptation of working in a virtual environment, including tips on managing your team remotely (from daily huddles to weekly videos and structured virtual get-togethers), to advisory firms taking a fresh look at their office space decisions as lease renewals may be coming due in the midst of the shutdown, some tips on managing client meetings virtually, and why in the end the key to surviving and thriving in the midst of this pandemic shutdown is not just about figuring out whether and how to adapt by changing your mindset to view this as a positive turning point in your business (and then to decide what you're going to build towards from here!).
We also have several marketing-related articles this week, from suggestions of what any advisory firm can start doing to improve (virtual) communication and connection with clients and prospects, why it may be a good time to take a fresh look at your advisor website, tips on how to focus on and change your website to do a better job of turning visitors into qualified prospects and eventually clients (now that we have to rely on our websites more than ever!), and how even though clients commonly find prospective advisors through referrals it's still necessary to do the substantive work of really earning their trust.
We wrap up with three interesting articles, all around the theme of habits and personal productivity: the first is a reminder of the power of "keystone habits", and how finding just one or two positive anchor habits can help spiral the rest of our lives in a more positive direction; the second is a fascinating look at mathematician and computer scientist Stephen Wolfram and the 'personal infrastructure' he has created to make himself more productive; and the last is a powerful reminder that in the end, the pandemic shutdown hasn't necessarily given us more time to be productive (as though we weren't already trying to be productive in the past!), it has just shifted our time, and the real key to productivity remains as it always was: not finding more time in the day, or a way to cram more things into the time that's available, but instead figuring out what you truly need to be doing yourself to be productive... and learning to hyperfocus your time on only those things that really, truly, matter the most!
Enjoy the 'light' reading!
Enjoy the current installment of "weekend reading for financial planners" – this week's edition kicks off with the news of a new show to debut this weekend on CNBC that will feature not stock-picking entertainment but actual financial planning advice from real financial advisors (featuring advisor and media personality Josh Brown) in what may be the most visible attempt yet to burnish the public image of what it means to be a "financial advisor" away from existing negative portrayals like Wolf of Wall Street and Ozark.
Also in the news this week is an update to the SEC's Frequently Asked Questions guidance on Regulation Best Interest reaffirming that standalone broker-dealers will be required to stop using the "advisor" title after June 30th (though dually-registered broker-dealer/RIAs will still be permitted to do so, even when acting as a broker and not an RIA), registration is opening for a new online version of FINRA and NASAA Series 6, 7, 63, and 65 exams as Prometric testing centers look to stay closed for at least several more weeks in many areas (while the CFP Board has announced that the July CFP exam is being delayed to September to allow more time for in-person testing centers to open where the more comprehensive exam can be effectively proctored), a recent Fidelity study finds advisors are buying more active than passive funds in the midst of the current market volatility (though it may simply be because advisors who use active funds are more likely to actively manage them in the first place), FPA launches a "Virtual Externship" program for college students to get up to 160 hours of CFP experience if their prior in-person internships were cancelled, and a new study finds that it's the frequency of advisor-client interactions and the transparency of the advisor's compensation that drives perceived value from clients (more so than just "how much" the advisor charges and whether it's more or less than what other advisors charge).
From there, we have several articles around client communication and relationship-building, including a look at how therapists are adapting to a more virtual environment with their patients (with some lessons for financial advisors communicating with clients), how to be more mindful of whether what you're saying to clients is really empathetic or not (hint: any sentence that starts with "at least... [it isn't worse]" isn't actually very empathetic), and a reminder that it's almost impossible to really know what others are going through so even when they share their troubles it's a good idea to pause and say "tell me more about that" before just trying to (empathetically) respond without necessarily understanding what their true concern actually is.
We wrap up with three interesting articles, all around the theme of how businesses and their employees can and are continuing to adapt to the work-from-home environment and the potential of returning back to the office in the coming month: the first explores how a renewed focus on employee safety (from the potential transmission of the coronavirus) may force offices to shift away from the open-office trend and back towards cubicles (with barriers to support social distancing!); the second provides some helpful tips on apps and tools to use to be more productive in a work-from-home environment; and the last provides a helpful reminder for anyone in a position of leadership about how to communicate more productively with employees in an era when virtual workplaces necessitate a more proactive communication approach.
Enjoy the 'light' reading!
Enjoy the current installment of "weekend reading for financial planners" – this week's edition kicks off with a new industry study from Broadridge finding that the coronavirus pandemic is just further accelerating the industry's shift towards more holistic financial planning as a way to demonstrate and add value in the midst of the turbulent market environment (particularly amongst advisors under age 40).
Also in the news this week is a new study finding that nearly 1/3rd of consumers still don't understand how financial advisors are compensated (undermining their trust in working with an advisor) and that getting a clear understanding of how the advisor is paid is even more important than the actual payment mechanism itself (e.g., commissions, AUM fees, fee-for-service, etc.), a discussion of whether advisors should be cutting fees in the current environment (particularly for their clients facing their own difficult financial situations), and the opportunity for advisors to work with their more affluent clients to make distributions from donor-advised funds to help charities that are trying to serve those most in need right now but may be struggling in the current environment.
From there, we have several articles on behavioral finance and helping clients through difficult environments, including tips on how to handle calls from clients who want to go to cash, how to (and how not to) position your 'behavioral coaching' as a value to clients and prospects, recent research showing that the more familiar an investor is with a stock, the more rapidly they tend to trade it (and the worse the results tend to be), an overview of the legal defensibility of various risk tolerance software tools (where some are far more robust than others if the advisor even had to defend their use of the tool in court), tips on what to look for (and what to avoid) in finding a valid and reliable risk tolerance assessment tool, and some guidance on what conversations to have with clients now while markets are calmer (to prepare for the possibility that they could become much more volatile again before the recession is over).
We wrap up with three interesting articles, all around the theme of how the industry itself is changing: the first looks at how in the last (financial) crisis, it was the firms that reinvested the most for growth despite the scary environment that ended out having the most success in the decade that followed; the second looks at the evolving trends in the industry that were already underway but may be accelerated by the coronavirus pandemic; and the last, a send-off from the soon-to-be-retiring Mark Tibergien, explores what financial advisors and the industry at large can do to make ourselves even more valuable in the aftermath of the coronavirus pandemic and the decade to come!
Enjoy the 'light' reading!
Enjoy the current installment of "weekend reading for financial planners" – this week's edition kicks off with latest tracking report on mergers and acquisitions of advisory firms, that finds firms in the first quarter of 2019 doing deals at a near-record pace... but at a volume that is still ultimately a minuscule fraction of the total number of advisory firms in the marketplace, and with storm clouds looming that advisory firm sales could quickly grind to a halt if a bear market emerges (and firm owners may not want to sell at depressed valuations on reduced AUM revenues). Also in the news this week is the somewhat surprising revelation that the Department of Labor is working on a new fiduciary rule... but this time, one that will from-the-start be written to conform to whatever the SEC puts forth in its final Regulation Best Interest rule.
We have several other regulatory-related articles as well, including a look at how the SEC is stepping up its scrutiny on Chief Compliance Officers (and whether RIAs really have a bona fide compliance oversight program in place for their firm), the new expectations that the SEC is setting forth for advisory firms working with seniors (including establishing policies for the firm about how to handle senior clients experiencing cognitive decline), and a recent high-profile case of an RIA that was fined $150,000 by the SEC for failing to disclose over the span of a decade its revenue-sharing solicitor arrangement with Fidelity's custodial referral program.
From there, we have several articles on advisor marketing and specifically websites, from the reasons why most advisory firm websites are useless (as even when they laud the benefits of the firm, they typically do so in the exact same undifferentiated way as every other advisory firm), updates to focus on first to make an advisory firm website look more modern, common blogging mistakes of advisors who are creating fresh content for their websites but aren't necessarily distributing or leveraging it properly, and an interesting look in what Baby Boomers really search for online using Google's Search tools (and why advisors are less likely to get clients with "10 Reasons Why Fiduciaries Deliver The Best Objective Transparent Financial Advice" and more likely to find prospects with "The Best Retirement Cake Inscriptions" instead... with, of course, the advisor's contact information in the byline at the end!).
We wrap up with three interesting articles, all around the theme of how the advisory industry is forever growing and changing: the first looks at how entrepreneurs may actually be better off by launching their firms alone rather than starting with a team of 2-3 co-founders (at least, as long as they're ready and willing to hire outside help in the areas they need it when they do need help); the second explores the evolution of the famous Andreessen Horowitz venture capital firm, and how the company is restructuring itself into an RIA (rather than a traditional VC firm) to have even more flexibility to make big focused bets with their client assets; and the last is a fascinating deep-dive into the evolution of Charles Schwab, and how the company grew from a discount broker for do-it-yourselfers into a mega-firm that's increasingly focused on the full range of financial services... including a growing footprint in financial planning as well.
Enjoy the "light" reading!
Enjoy the current installment of "weekend reading for financial planners" - this week's edition kicks off with a big AdvisorHub expose on the Barron's Top 100 Advisors list, finding that a whopping 60% of the advisors on the list over the past 5 years have had at least one disclosed consumer complaint, regulatory action, or criminal conviction (compared to "just" 7.8% of all brokers who have misconduct records, according to another recent controversial study).
From there, we have a number of technical financial planning articles this week, including a discussion of whether or how the CAPE ratio should be adjusted in today's market environment (and whether reasonable adjustments would show the market isn't as overvalued as the CAPE 10 implies), a new study finding that how stressful a job is may be one of the biggest predictors of whether people keep working well into their 60s, a look at just how ugly the statistics really are for those who play the lottery, and a good reminder that while the data increasingly shows how expensive actively managed funds lag index funds it's still worse to sit on the sidelines and not be invested at all.
There are also several practice management articles this week, including: how the internet made it easier to work virtually, but a surprising number of people still go to the office every day, or are seeking out new "co-working" spaces; the growing pressure on advisory firms to move up the "wealth management pyramid" to provide a greater level of value-add; why the key to success with advisor niches is not just niche marketing but actually crafting niche services; and a look at how the 12(b)-1 fee is in steady decline and being replaced by advisor AUM fees paid directly by the client instead, and how the DoL fiduciary rule may just further accelerate the trend.
We wrap up with three interesting articles: the first looks at how direct-to-consumer FinTech (e.g., robo-advisors) has been the hot area for the past several years, but "InsurTech" may be the next big technology trend (but given the challenges of direct-to-consumer insurance, may be even more likely to go through advisors rather than around them); the second is a look at how even Goldman Sachs is getting into FinTech with a new online bank offering, but that the reasoning may be more about old-world bank liquidity ratios than a next generation consumer push; and the last is a fascinating look at how the entire asset management industry is being disrupted from multiple directions all at once.
And be certain to check out Bill Winterberg's "Bits & Bytes" video on the latest in advisor tech news at the end, which this week includes coverage of Redtail CRM's announcements of integrations with both Morningstar and Zapier, the new release of MoneyGuidePro's G4, and highlights of the National Association of Broadcasters (NAB) annual trade show with all the latest (easy-to-use and affordable) audio and video equipment that advisors can use to create their own content.
Enjoy the "light" reading!
